I completely agree with this format you suggest Soggy. I think you would need a third page for all of the badges. But I'd like to see it go even a step further and what you have left or collect over starts on the next badge.
How the FA should work is you go in and do your regular collections and then you open that page and collect your badges, and if it was 12 hours since you last got on, you might have 3 guard badges instead of one. And those 50 workshops making toolkits, well, open the FA badge pop-up after collecting and there are 10 badges there.
Why can't we just have that to look at where we are on our badges, and have the badges just scroll, "+1 blacksmith" kind of thing?
And some badges a just dumb. What have the 100 goods with the spell badges? Seriously, collect a spell from the tournament, go to the main page, collect 100 goods, scroll through upteen other badges to get back to that spell badge, reload the map, and do the next province. It was not designed for fun! Those badges should just be the spells and when we collect a spell it should just add to our inventory.
And speaking of inventory, how's this for trying to communicate with the rest of the FA, go to the FA page, scroll to see what your have, try to enter into the group FA spreadsheet, game locks ups after and entry, reload the game, go back to the FA page, get one or two more badges recorded on the FA spreadsheet before the game crashes again... Same deal with the crashing when you try and communicate via the email, from data in the spreadsheet.
This is just an unnecessary step because there are NO FA management tools. We should be able to see how many we have of a badge, and at least the total between all players in the fellowship.
IMO a drop down is the weakest fix. If they are going to overhaul it and implement something new, they should go with @lord drac's idea:
View attachment 4269